Getting arrested in Maryland typically will lead to facing criminal charges in the court system.
In most cases, when someone alleges that you committed a crime, it will lead to the filing of something called an “incident of abuse,” which will often lead to police investigating the allegations. If the police determine that they have “probable cause” that the offense alleged occurred, they will seek out an arrest warrant.
To execute the warrant, a prosecutor and just must sign off on the warrant and agree that there is probable cause for the offense. Probable cause is one of the lowest standards in the law and basically is equivalent to a “reason to believe” the offense occurred. Now, getting arrested does not mean that you will automatically be convicted. For the State to convict you of a criminal offense, the government must prove the elements of an offense beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the highest standard of proof under the law.
Getting Arrested in Maryland
Once arrested, the police will book and process the person and they will go before a Commissioner for a determination on bail or conditions of release. After the initial pretrial hearing, the case gets forwarded to the State’s Attorney’s Office for prosecution. Usually, during a prosecution of any offense, the defendant will only have two choices: accept a plea bargain negotiated by a lawyer or take the case to trial.
A plea bargain typically involves the State reducing or dropping some charges in exchange the defendant waiving their constitutional rights. These rights include, among other things, the right to a trial, the right to confront witnesses, the right to testify (or not testify), the right to compel exculpatory witnesses to testify on your behalf, and the right to an appeal.
However, in some instances, a third option is available called diversion. Maryland has a couple different types of diversion options available in some cases. One is called putting the case on a “stet docket.” That basically means that the prosecution decides not to go forward and the case goes inactive so long as the defendant either completes certain conditions like community service or takes certain classes or so long as the defendant does not get rearrested.
Another option at sentencing is where a judge may put someone in Maryland on Probation before Judgment (often referred to as a “PBJ”). In cases where the defendant gets a PBJ, the defendant must successfully complete probation before a judgment (or conviction is entered). If the defendant completes probation successfully, then the conviction never gets entered and often the case gets expunged.
Going to Trial in Maryland
In addition, if a defendant makes a jury demand, that will result in the case that may have started in District Court getting moved to Circuit Court. At a trial, the State must prove every element of the offense charged beyond a reasonable doubt. That means they must put witnesses on the stand who will testify under oath to what they observed. The defense can cross-examine the government’s witnesses and confront any allegations made. In addition, the defense can subpoena or compel witnesses who may come forward and testify favorably for the defendant.
In a jury trial, the judge will instruct jurors (usually 12 members of the community) on what the law is regarding the offense the State has charged. Its up to the jury to decide what the facts of the case are. The jury assesses the credibility of the witnesses and decides who they believe and what they think happened. Not only must they decide what facts they believe, they must believe them beyond a reasonable doubt if the facts support a conviction.
Beyond a reasonable doubt is something we all hear on television but often do not think about what it actually means. It means the State’s evidence must be so convincing that we have no reason to doubt its true. That means the jurors could think its likely the defendant committed the offense but if they have a doubt (not just any doubt but a doubt based on reason) they must acquit the defendant to properly apply the law as instructed.
In a bench trial, however, the judge makes both the factual findings and applies those facts to the law. That means the judge must assess the credibility of the witnesses and decide which version of facts they believe occurred. If the judge properly applies the standard beyond a reasonable doubt, she two must only convict if that high standard is met. Finally, its important to remember that the burden of proof never shifts the defendant. It always remains on the State to prove the offense. While many defendants put on a legal defense, they are not legally required to do it.
Hiring a Maryland Criminal Lawyer
If you or someone you know has been arrested or charged with a criminal offense in Maryland, contact Morgan E. Leigh today for a full case evaluation.